LUXURY GUIDE
Two Historic Neighborhoods, Two Distinct Price Points
Pemberton is the estate side and Old Enfield the cottage side, both within the Old West Austin National Register Historic District.
Data through Nov. 11, 2026 · Updated quarterly · Source: Unlock MLS
Last 12 months
MEDIAN PRICE
$1.50M
3 yrs: $1.55M
TYPICAL DAYS TO SELL
45
3 yrs: 47
SALE TO ORIGINAL LIST
91.3%
3 yrs: 89.6%
PRICE PER SQ FT
$694
3 yrs: $692
Two Neighborhoods, Two Price Points
Pemberton Heights homes sold for a median of $2.2M, at $728 per square foot, and the typical house is about 3,400 square feet on a quarter acre.
See the analysis
Pemberton Heights and Old Enfield sit side by side between MoPac and Shoal Creek, a few minutes from downtown and the Capitol. Both are part of the Old West Austin National Register Historic District. Over the last three years 75 single-family homes sold here: Pemberton is the estate side, and Old Enfield is the cottage side.
Old Enfield homes sold for a median of $1.23M at $636 per square foot, with about 2,100 square feet on a sixth of an acre. Both took about seven weeks to sell and closed near 90% of their original list price, and 2026 has been firmer: 91.9% of original list in 43 days.
Pemberton was developed in twelve sections from 1927 into the early 1940s by the Fisher family's Austin Land Company, around the 1890s water tower that became Pemberton Castle. Old Enfield grew from Governor Elisha Pease's Woodlawn estate and is known for its colonial-style homes. Pemberton is generally zoned to Casis Elementary, O. Henry Middle and Austin High; Old Enfield streets split between Casis and Mathews Elementary, so confirm each address with Austin ISD. Pease Park and the Shoal Creek trail run along the east side, and Lamar's shops, downtown and UT are minutes away.
By Neighborhood
| Neighborhood | Sales | Median price | Median $/sq ft | Median size | Median lot | Median days | Sold and original list |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pemberton Heights | 35 | $2.20M | $728 | 3,415 sq ft | 0.24 ac | 47 | 89.6% |
| Old Enfield | 40 | $1.23M | $636 | 2,133 sq ft | 0.16 ac | 49 | 89.8% |
Well-Priced Homes Sell Close to List
The homes that sold in the first two weeks closed at almost 99% of their first price.
See the analysis
Well-Priced Homes Sell Close to List
Sold price as a share of original list price, by time on market.
Historic Homes, Rare New Construction
Most homes here were built before 1960, and the 1930s homes hold their value: 39 sales built before 1940 closed at a median $1.44M and 90.9% of original list.
See the analysis
New construction is rare. Only nine homes built since 2015 sold in three years, and they went in about three weeks at 94.9% of original list for a median $2.97M and $873 per square foot.
Restoration pays here. One 1939 Pemberton home sold for $2.8M in 2024 and, after a renovation and addition, for $5.2M in 2026. The four sales above $5M were a 2024 new build, two restored 1930s homes and a 1991 estate on Niles Road.
Because both neighborhoods sit in a National Register historic district, demolition and major exterior changes to older homes can trigger city historic review. Plan time for it before you buy to rebuild.
Home Age at Sale
| Built | Sales | Median price | Median $/sq ft | Median days | Sold and original list |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before 1940 | 39 | $1.44M | $692 | 42 | 90.9% |
| 1940–1959 | 16 | $1.64M | $635 | 50 | 87.7% |
| 1960–2014 | 11 | $1.60M | $699 | 75 | 86.5% |
| 2015 and newer | 9 | $2.97M | $873 | 21 | 94.9% |
Price Range
Under $1.5M, mostly Old Enfield cottages, homes sold in about six weeks at 91.3% of original list.
See the analysis
The $1.5M–$3M middle was the softest band, at 87.8% after 53 days. Above $3M, mostly Pemberton, homes sold in 40 days at 90.5%.
By Price Range
| Range | Sales | Median price | Median $/sq ft | Median days | Sold and original list |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Under $1.5M | 34 | $1.11M | $606 | 44 | 91.3% |
| $1.5M–$3M | 24 | $1.83M | $716 | 53 | 87.8% |
| $3M and up | 17 | $3.88M | $878 | 40 | 90.5% |
Days on Market
| Days | Sales | Median price | Median days | Sold and original list |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0–14 | 19 | $1.63M | 6 | 98.6% |
| 15–60 | 26 | $1.54M | 41 | 91.6% |
| 61–120 | 10 | $2.03M | 90 | 85.8% |
| 121+ | 20 | $1.46M | 161 | 80.6% |
By Year
| Year | Sales | Median price | Median days | Sold and original list |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 | 23 | $1.95M | 53 | 87.0% |
| 2025 | 32 | $1.36M | 46 | 91.0% |
| 2026 (to Nov. 11) | 18 | $1.58M | 43 | 91.9% |
How David Looks at a Home Here
Architecture matters more here than almost anywhere in Austin. A well-restored 1930s Colonial or Tudor is the product buyers want; original details, proportions and the street view carry real value.
See the analysis
- Architecture matters more here than almost anywhere in Austin. A well-restored 1930s Colonial or Tudor is the product buyers want; original details, proportions and the street view carry real value.
- Condition is the whole negotiation. Buyers here pay for homes that have been cared for and push hard on deferred maintenance, foundations and old systems.
- Know the historic rules before you plan. Additions and rebuilds are possible but take longer, which affects what a lot is worth to a builder.
- Location inside the neighborhood. Street, lot and setting vary block to block, so David prices each home against its closest comparable sales, not the neighborhood median.
- Schools and private-school access. Proximity to Casis and to St. Andrew's and St. Stephen's is part of the appeal for many families.
What This Means for Sellers
Invest in condition before you list and price for the first two weeks.
See the analysis
Fast sales here closed at nearly full price; homes that sat lost 14% to 19%. If your home is a true restoration candidate, show buyers the upside rather than discounting for it.
What This Means for Buyers
Well-kept homes go quickly and close near asking.
See the analysis
Your room is in homes that need work and in listings past 60 days. If you plan a major renovation, budget time for historic review and for older-home surprises.
How these numbers are measured
Headline cards: last 12 months. Tables and charts: last 3 years. Source: Unlock MLS (ACTRIS), 75 closed single-family sales in Pemberton Heights (35) and Old Enfield (40), ZIP 78703, Nov. 2023 to Nov. 2026, grouped by subdivision and street. Medians; information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Thinking about selling in Pemberton or Old Enfield?
Source: Unlock MLS (ACTRIS), 75 closed single-family sales in Pemberton Heights (35) and Old Enfield (40), ZIP 78703, Nov. 2023 to Nov. 2026, grouped by subdivision and street. Medians; information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Headline cards: last 12 months. Tables and charts: last 3 years.
Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. The Austin Board of REALTORS®, ACTRIS and their affiliates provide the MLS and its content as-is, without warranty.
Listing expired or withdrawn? Request a complimentary review.
