LUXURY GUIDE
In Tarrytown, the Lot Often Matters as Much as the House
The market turns on one question: is the buyer paying for the home, or for the land beneath it?
Data through Nov. 11, 2026 · Updated quarterly · Source: Unlock MLS
Last 12 months
MEDIAN PRICE
$1.90M
3 yrs: $2.0M
TYPICAL DAYS TO SELL
39
3 yrs: 42
SALE TO ORIGINAL LIST
90.5%
3 yrs: 90.5%
PRICE PER SQ FT
$630
3 yrs: $687
Tarrytown at a Glance
The median Tarrytown home sold for about $2.0 million over the last three years, at $687 per square foot, after 42 days on market and at 90.5% of its original list price.
See the analysis
Tarrytown runs from MoPac to Lake Austin and from Enfield Road to West 35th Street, about two miles from downtown. Over the last three years 236 single-family homes sold here. The market splits on one question: is the buyer paying for the house, or for the lot under it?
The typical house is about 3,070 square feet on a 0.22-acre lot. Prices have held steady: the median was $2.1M in 2024, $2.0M in 2025 and $1.92M so far in 2026, while 2026 homes are selling faster (36 days) and closer to their first price (90.9%).
The neighborhood took its name from the Graham family's summer retreat in Tarrytown, New York, and its first section opened in 1934 on land that was once Governor Elisha Pease's Woodlawn estate. Most homes are zoned to Casis Elementary, O. Henry Middle and Austin High (confirm each address with Austin ISD). Daily life centers on Tarrytown Center and Casis Village, with Lake Austin, Mayfield Park, Laguna Gloria, Lions Municipal Golf Course and Deep Eddy Pool close by.
The First Two Weeks Set the Price
Priced right, Tarrytown homes keep about 98% of their launch price.
See the analysis
The First Two Weeks Set the Price
Sold price as a share of the original list price, grouped by how long the home sat on market.
House or Lot: How a Home's Age Changes Its Value
Nearly half of Tarrytown's sales were homes built before 1960.
See the analysis
The smaller originals are usually priced as land: 36 pre-1960 homes under 2,000 square feet sold at a median of $1.16M, roughly $133 per square foot of land on about a fifth of an acre. A home built since 2015 on a similar street sold at a median of $3.0M and $820 per square foot. The spread between those two numbers is what builders and buyers are really negotiating.
Since 2024, Austin's HOME rules allow up to three homes on many single-family lots and small lots down to 1,800 square feet. That changes what some Tarrytown lots are worth to a builder, but private deed restrictions on older plats can still limit it, so check before assuming.
Home Age at Sale
| Built | Sales | Median price | Median $/sq ft | Median days | Sold and original list |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before 1960 | 112 | $1.50M | $647 | 39 | 90.2% |
| 1960–1999 | 37 | $2.08M | $618 | 61 | 90.2% |
| 2000–2014 | 41 | $2.43M | $680 | 52 | 89.6% |
| 2015 and newer | 46 | $3.03M | $820 | 47 | 91.5% |
Neighborhood by Neighborhood
Tarrytown's pockets are closer to each other than Westlake's, but they are not the same market.
See the analysis
Lot size, lake proximity and street traffic drive most of the difference.
- Lake side (Pecos Street, Scenic Drive, Bowman Place, Bello Vista) — 39 sales, median $2.64M, 45 days, 90.0% of original list. The largest lots and three of the neighborhood's six highest sales, near Lake Austin and Mayfield Park. Waterfront and view lots trade on their own comps.
- Westfield (the Enfield Road side, around Lions Municipal Golf Course) — 43 sales, median $2.12M, 69 days, 89.7%. Strong prices but the longest marketing times in Tarrytown; two of the top six sales were here.
- Central Tarrytown (Windsor Road, Bowman Avenue, Mountain View) — 62 sales, median $2.05M, 38 days, 91.4%. The original Tarry Town sections, walkable to Tarrytown Center and Casis Elementary. The most consistent pocket.
- North Tarrytown (Bonnie Road, Bridle Path, Laurel Heights toward West 35th) — 59 sales, median $1.80M, 40 days, 90.5%. Slightly smaller lots and the best entry point near Laguna Gloria and the 35th Street shops.
- Exposition corridor (Tarrytown Oaks and homes fronting Exposition Boulevard) — 27 sales, median $1.67M, 36 days, 87.8%, $579 per square foot. Busy-street frontage costs real money here; the deepest discount and lowest price per foot in the neighborhood.
Pockets
| Sales | Median price | Median $/sq ft | Median days | Sold and original list | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lake side | 39 | $2.64M | $694 | 45 | 90.0% |
| Westfield | 43 | $2.12M | $697 | 69 | 89.7% |
| Central Tarrytown | 62 | $2.05M | $705 | 38 | 91.4% |
| North Tarrytown | 59 | $1.80M | $696 | 40 | 90.5% |
| Exposition corridor | 27 | $1.67M | $579 | 36 | 87.8% |
Price Range and Lot Size
The $1.5M–$3M range is Tarrytown's core: 130 of 236 sales, selling in about five weeks at 91.8% of original list.
See the analysis
Above $3M, homes took twice as long (76 days). Under $1.5M, buyers negotiated hardest (87.0%), because most of those homes are lot-value purchases. Lots of 0.3 acres or more sold for a median $2.70M versus $1.62M under 0.2 acres.
By Price Range
| Range | Sales | Median price | Median $/sq ft | Median days | Sold and original list |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Under $1.5M | 66 | $1.16M | $570 | 48 | 87.0% |
| $1.5M–$3M | 130 | $2.14M | $686 | 36 | 91.8% |
| $3M–$5M | 32 | $3.46M | $838 | 76 | 91.4% |
| $5M and up | 8 | $7.59M | $1,221 | 55 | 88.8% |
By Lot Size
| Lot | Sales | Median price | Median $/sq ft | Median days | Sold and original list |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Under 0.20 acre | 88 | $1.62M | $661 | 34 | 90.7% |
| 0.20–0.30 acre | 100 | $1.95M | $676 | 37 | 91.2% |
| 0.30 acre and up | 48 | $2.70M | $739 | 64 | 89.9% |
Days on Market
| Days | Sales | Median price | Median days | Sold and original list |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0–14 | 66 | $1.86M | 5 | 97.6% |
| 15–60 | 67 | $2.14M | 33 | 91.2% |
| 61–120 | 48 | $2.17M | 87 | 85.9% |
| 121+ | 52 | $1.92M | 174 | 81.3% |
How David Evaluates a Tarrytown Home
Lot first. Size, shape, slope and mature trees set the floor.
See the analysis
- Lot first. Size, shape, slope and mature trees set the floor. Austin protects heritage trees, so a large oak can make a lot more beautiful and harder to build on at the same time.
- The street matters. Interior streets near Casis and Tarrytown Center hold value; Exposition and Enfield frontage trade at a discount.
- Character and teardown. A well-kept 1930s or 1940s colonial or cottage can sell on charm. A dated ranch on a big lot is usually priced as land, and the architecture adds little.
- New construction is judged on livability. Above $3M, buyers compare layout, light, outdoor space and finish quality against every recent build, which is why those homes take longer.
- Lake access is its own market. View and waterfront lots on the lake side need their own comps, not neighborhood medians.
What This Means for Sellers
Price for the first two weeks.
See the analysis
Tarrytown's data is unusually clear: the homes that sold fast kept almost all of their price, and the ones that sat gave up 14% to 19%. Decide early whether your buyer is a family buying a house or a builder buying a lot, and market to that buyer.
What This Means for Buyers
In the $1.5M–$3M core, good homes go quickly and near asking.
See the analysis
Your leverage is with homes past 60 days, lot-value houses under $1.5M, and busy-street frontage. If you are buying to build, budget for the lot, the trees and the deed restrictions before the house.
How these numbers are measured
Headline cards: last 12 months. Tables and charts: last 3 years. Source: Unlock MLS (ACTRIS), 236 closed single-family sales in Tarrytown (ZIP 78703, MoPac to Lake Austin, Enfield Road to West 35th Street), Nov. 2023 to Nov. 2026. Pockets grouped by subdivision and street. Medians; information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Thinking about selling in Tarrytown?
Source: Unlock MLS (ACTRIS), 236 closed single-family sales in Tarrytown (ZIP 78703, MoPac to Lake Austin, Enfield Road to West 35th Street), Nov. 2023 to Nov. 2026. Pockets grouped by subdivision and street. Medians; information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Headline cards: last 12 months. Tables and charts: last 3 years.
Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. The Austin Board of REALTORS®, ACTRIS and their affiliates provide the MLS and its content as-is, without warranty.
Listing expired or withdrawn? Request a complimentary review.
